6600 Estate Smith Bay, St. Thomas, St. Thomas, 00802, VI
Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
honest review
Is Point Pleasant Resort Worth It? Honest Review (Pros, Cons & Who It's Best For)
Trying to decide whether Point Pleasant Resort is worth booking? This in-depth guide breaks down the real pros and cons, including hillside views, villa-style kitchens, private balconies or patios, three outdoor pools, Sugar Beach access, dining options, shuttle convenience, family-friendly appeal, and mobility considerations—so you can confidently judge whether it matches your travel style. Whether you want scenic St. Thomas value, a self-catering villa setup, or a resort base with character and ocean views, this breakdown shows who Point Pleasant Resort suits best and where expectations matter.
Planning your stay guide
Wondering "Is Point Pleasant Resort worth it?" This honest review explains the real value of this all-ages waterfront resort on Water Bay, St. Thomas—what's amazing, what's not, and who it's best for (families, couples seeking privacy, island explorers, and travelers who want villa-style accommodations with Caribbean authenticity).
Quick verdict:
Yes—Point Pleasant Resort is worth it if you want villa-style accommodations with full kitchens, hillside ocean views, private beach access, and a relaxed Caribbean atmosphere on St. Thomas. It's less ideal if you want a traditional full-service resort with multiple restaurants, nightly entertainment, or prefer staying on flat, walkable terrain without hills.
Best for: families + couples seeking privacy
Best vibe: villa-style Caribbean escape
Best length: 5–7 nights
Not ideal for: those wanting all-inclusive dining
Tip: This resort's signature appeal is "villa privacy + authentic Caribbean setting"—perfect for travelers who want self-catered flexibility with stunning ocean views.
Jump to a section
Explore the resort
Continue planning your stay at Point Pleasant Resort with these quick guides. Explore villa categories and accommodation options, learn about Lionfish Restaurant, preview resort amenities and activities, and discover the private beach and pool areas—so you can book the best experience for your St. Thomas getaway.
Is Point Pleasant Resort Worth It?
For most travelers looking for a villa-style all-ages resort in St. Thomas with authentic Caribbean character, Point Pleasant Resort is worth it because it delivers unique advantages: spacious villas with full kitchens and ocean views, private beach access at Water Bay, hillside tropical setting, family-friendly atmosphere, and the flexibility to self-cater or dine at Lionfish Restaurant—all within a more intimate, residential-style Caribbean resort experience.
Worth it if you want…
- Villa-style accommodations with full kitchens and private balconies
- Hillside ocean views overlooking Water Bay and the Caribbean
- Private beach access with calm, snorkel-friendly water
- All-ages family-friendly atmosphere with children's facilities
- Flexibility to cook in-villa or dine at Lionfish Restaurant
- Authentic Caribbean setting away from mega-resort commercialization
- Easy access to St. Thomas attractions and Red Hook ferry terminal
Not worth it if you want…
- Multiple on-site restaurants and bars (only Lionfish Restaurant on property)
- Traditional all-inclusive meal plans and unlimited dining options
- Flat, completely walkable terrain (hillside location requires navigating slopes)
- Nightly entertainment programming and resort activities
- Full-service concierge and daily housekeeping (villa-style means more independence)
- Being directly in Charlotte Amalie or Cruz Bay for nightlife
Best-trip formula: Book 5–7 nights, plan 1-2 island excursions (snorkeling trips, island tours, or day trips to St. John), stock your villa kitchen with groceries from nearby markets, and balance beach days with exploring St. Thomas—maximizing your villa privacy and island flexibility.
Point Pleasant Resort Pros & Cons (Honest Breakdown)
Top pros
- Spacious villa accommodations with full kitchens, living areas, and private balconies
- Stunning hillside ocean views from most villas overlooking Water Bay
- Private beach access at Water Bay with calm, clear water ideal for snorkeling
- Family-friendly atmosphere with facilities for children and all-ages activities
- Villa flexibility—cook your own meals or dine at Lionfish Restaurant
- Authentic Caribbean setting with lush tropical landscaping and local charm
- Close to Red Hook ferry terminal for easy day trips to St. John and BVI
- Multiple pools including main pool area and quiet relaxation spots
- More affordable than luxury mega-resorts while offering villa-style privacy
Top cons
- Limited on-site dining—only Lionfish Restaurant for meals and drinks
- Hillside location requires walking up and down slopes (may be challenging for mobility issues)
- Not a traditional full-service resort—more villa-rental independence
- No all-inclusive meal plans or unlimited dining options
- Beach is smaller and more intimate than large resort beaches
- Limited nightly entertainment and organized activities compared to mega-resorts
- Housekeeping may be less frequent than traditional hotels (villa-style service)
- Requires rental car recommended for exploring St. Thomas attractions
What to Expect at Point Pleasant Resort
This section covers what travelers actually search for: villa accommodations and categories, beach quality, dining options, location advantages, and whether the hillside villa setting delivers good value for your St. Thomas vacation.
Villa accommodations
Point Pleasant Resort offers villa-style accommodations ranging from ocean view suites to multi-bedroom villas. All villas feature full kitchens, living areas, private balconies or terraces, and most include stunning ocean views overlooking Water Bay.
- Available categories: Ocean View Suite, Studio, 1 Bedroom Ocean View Villa, Deluxe 1 Bedroom Ocean View Villa, 2 Bedroom Ocean View Villa, Three-Bedroom Villa Mermaids Hideout
- All villas include: full kitchen, living area, private balcony/terrace, ceiling fans
- Best for: families who want space, couples seeking privacy, groups traveling together
- Tip: book ocean view categories for the best Water Bay panoramas
Beach & pools
The resort's private beach at Water Bay is a major highlight—calm, clear water perfect for swimming and snorkeling, with a more intimate, less-crowded atmosphere than larger resort beaches. Multiple pools offer variety for relaxation.
- Beach quality: calm, clear Caribbean water with excellent snorkeling
- Beach atmosphere: intimate and peaceful, not crowded mega-resort style
- Pool options: main pool area plus quieter pool spots throughout property
- Tip: mornings offer calmest water and best snorkeling visibility
Dining: Lionfish Restaurant
Lionfish Restaurant is the resort's on-site dining venue, offering Caribbean-inspired cuisine with fresh seafood and island specialties. The villa kitchens give you flexibility to self-cater, shop at local markets, or dine out at nearby restaurants.
- On-site option: Lionfish Restaurant for breakfast, lunch, and dinner
- Villa kitchens: full cooking facilities for preparing your own meals
- Nearby options: Red Hook area has grocery stores and local restaurants
- Best strategy: mix Lionfish dining with villa cooking and exploring local spots
Location & island access
Point Pleasant Resort's East End St. Thomas location near Red Hook provides excellent access to island attractions, ferry terminals for St. John and BVI day trips, and a more residential, authentic Caribbean neighborhood.
- Distance to Red Hook: 5-10 minutes (ferry terminal for St. John/BVI)
- Distance to Charlotte Amalie: 20-25 minutes (capital, cruise port, shopping)
- Airport transfer: approximately 30-40 minutes from Cyril E. King Airport
- Car rental: recommended for exploring beaches, restaurants, and attractions
How to Decide If It's Worth It (Fast Value Checklist)
| Question | If "yes"… | If "no"… |
|---|---|---|
| Do you want villa-style accommodations with full kitchens? | Point Pleasant Resort is an excellent match. | Traditional hotel rooms may be more suitable. |
| Are you comfortable with hillside terrain and slopes? | The hillside setting provides stunning ocean views. | Flat, walkable resorts may be better for mobility concerns. |
| Will you cook some meals in your villa? | Full kitchens maximize value and flexibility. | All-inclusive resorts may offer better dining convenience. |
| Do you prefer intimate, authentic Caribbean over mega-resorts? | Point Pleasant delivers authentic island character. | Large resorts with more amenities might feel more suitable. |
| Will you rent a car to explore St. Thomas? | Location is ideal for island exploration and day trips. | Walkable resorts near Charlotte Amalie may be more convenient. |
Tips to Make Your Stay Feel More "Worth It"
Book the optimal length of stay
Most travelers maximize value at 5–7 nights. This gives you time to settle into your villa, enjoy beach days, take day trips to St. John or nearby cays, explore St. Thomas attractions, and truly relax without feeling rushed.
- 4-5 nights = quick island getaway with villa privacy
- 6-7 nights = ideal balance of beach relaxation + island exploration
- 7+ nights = maximum beach time with multiple excursion opportunities
Stock your villa kitchen strategically
Take advantage of your full kitchen by shopping at nearby grocery stores in Red Hook. Stock breakfast items, snacks, and simple lunch ingredients—this saves money and maximizes your villa flexibility.
- Shop on arrival: Red Hook area has grocery stores within 10 minutes
- Best strategy: cook breakfast and lunch, dine out or at Lionfish for dinner
- Bring basics: coffee, condiments, and favorite snacks from home
- Local markets: support island vendors for fresh produce and local specialties
Point Pleasant Villa Categories: Which One Is Right for You?
Choosing the right villa category impacts your experience significantly. Here's how to decide between Point Pleasant Resort's available villa types based on your group size, budget, and preferences.
Studio & Ocean View Suite
- Best for: couples or solo travelers
- Space: compact yet comfortable with kitchenette or full kitchen
- Views: ocean views from most units
- Value: best budget option for villa-style privacy
1 & 2 Bedroom Ocean View Villas
- Best for: small families or 2-4 travelers
- Space: separate bedrooms, full kitchen, living area
- Views: stunning ocean vistas overlooking Water Bay
- Value: ideal balance of space and price for most travelers
Three-Bedroom Villa Mermaids Hideout
- Best for: large families or groups up to 6-8
- Space: maximum privacy with multiple bedrooms and bathrooms
- Views: premium ocean views with ample terrace space
- Value: best per-person rate for larger groups traveling together
Quick recommendation: Book 1 or 2 Bedroom Ocean View Villas for the best balance of space, views, and value. Upgrade to Deluxe 1 Bedroom Ocean View Villa if you want enhanced amenities. Choose Three-Bedroom Villa Mermaids Hideout for large families or groups to maximize space and split costs.
FAQ: Is Point Pleasant Resort Worth It?
Is Point Pleasant Resort worth it for families?
Yes—especially for families who want villa-style accommodations with full kitchens, private beach access, and all-ages facilities on St. Thomas. The spacious villas with separate bedrooms and living areas provide much more space than traditional hotel rooms, and the family-friendly atmosphere makes children feel welcome throughout the resort.
Is Point Pleasant Resort worth it for couples?
Absolutely, especially for couples seeking privacy, ocean views, and authentic Caribbean ambiance. The villa accommodations offer more privacy than traditional hotel rooms, hillside settings provide romantic ocean vistas, and the intimate beach atmosphere feels more exclusive than crowded mega-resort beaches. It's ideal for couples who value independence and villa flexibility.
What's the best length of stay at Point Pleasant Resort?
5–7 nights is optimal for most travelers. This allows time to settle into your villa, enjoy beach days at Water Bay, take day trips to St. John or nearby attractions, explore St. Thomas restaurants and beaches, and truly relax without feeling rushed. Villa-style stays feel more valuable with longer durations.
How does Point Pleasant Resort compare to traditional St. Thomas hotels?
Point Pleasant Resort stands out for its villa-style accommodations with full kitchens, hillside ocean views, private beach access, and authentic Caribbean character. It's more independent and residential than traditional full-service hotels, which means more privacy and flexibility but fewer on-site dining options (only Lionfish Restaurant). Best for travelers who want villa space and self-catering flexibility over all-inclusive meal plans.
When is Point Pleasant Resort NOT worth it?
It may not be worth it if you want multiple on-site restaurants and bars, prefer traditional all-inclusive dining plans, need completely flat terrain without hills, want nightly entertainment programming, or prefer being directly in Charlotte Amalie for nightlife. Travelers who want full-service resort amenities without cooking in-villa may prefer traditional hotels with more dining variety.
Do I need a rental car at Point Pleasant Resort?
Yes, a rental car is highly recommended to maximize your St. Thomas experience. While the resort provides beach access and on-site dining at Lionfish Restaurant, having a car gives you freedom to explore island beaches, restaurants in Red Hook and beyond, take day trips, shop at grocery stores for villa cooking, and visit attractions like Magens Bay, Charlotte Amalie, and ferry terminals for St. John trips.
What makes the hillside location worth it despite the slopes?
The hillside setting provides stunning panoramic ocean views that wouldn't be possible with flat beachfront locations. Most villas feature breathtaking vistas overlooking Water Bay and the Caribbean, creating a more dramatic and memorable visual experience. While the slopes require some walking, the views and privacy make it worthwhile for most travelers who can navigate moderate terrain.