6600 Estate Smith Bay, St. Thomas, St. Thomas, 00802, VI
Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
dining
Point Pleasant Resort Restaurants Ranked (Best Food, Best Ambience, Best Value)
Trying to decide where to eat at Point Pleasant Resort? This in-depth guide ranks the resort’s dining options by food quality, waterfront ambience, menu variety, dress code, reservation usefulness, and overall value—so you can confidently choose the best meals for your stay. Whether you want relaxed open-air dining overlooking Water Bay, a more polished dinner with Caribbean-influenced flavors, or the easiest family-friendly spot for breakfast, lunch, cocktails, and casual bites, this breakdown shows which restaurants are worth prioritizing and what to expect before you go.
Resort dining guide
Looking for the best restaurant at Point Pleasant Resort? This guide covers your main on-site dining option—Lionfish Restaurant—and what travelers actually care about: menu highlights, ambience, and best times to dine—so you can plan your meals during your St. Thomas stay, decide when to eat on-site vs. explore local restaurants nearby, and make the most of your family-friendly villa resort experience.
Quick takeaway:
Point Pleasant Resort has one on-site restaurant—Lionfish Restaurant—offering oceanfront Caribbean-inspired dining with fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and sunset views. It's perfect for relaxed family dinners, romantic evenings, and casual lunches. Most guests balance on-site meals with exploring nearby dining options in Red Hook and Charlotte Amalie.
Point Pleasant Resort has one on-site restaurant—Lionfish Restaurant—offering oceanfront Caribbean-inspired dining with fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and sunset views. It's perfect for relaxed family dinners, romantic evenings, and casual lunches. Most guests balance on-site meals with exploring nearby dining options in Red Hook and Charlotte Amalie.
Best for: oceanfront dining + sunset views
Top pick: fresh Caribbean seafood
Great for: families + couples
Jump to a section
Explore the resort
Continue planning your stay at Point Pleasant Resort with these quick guides. Explore villa categories and oceanfront layouts, preview activities and nearby attractions, and learn about beach access, pools, and family-friendly amenities—so you can book the best villa experience in St. Thomas.
Dining Overview at Point Pleasant Resort
Point Pleasant Resort takes a different approach than all-inclusive properties—it's a villa-style resort where most accommodations include full kitchens or kitchenettes, giving you the flexibility to cook, order in, or dine out. The resort has one on-site restaurant—Lionfish Restaurant—which serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner with oceanfront views and Caribbean-inspired cuisine.
Most guests mix on-site meals at Lionfish with grocery runs (there's a market nearby in Red Hook), casual takeout from local spots, and nights out at nearby restaurants in Red Hook, Frenchtown, and Charlotte Amalie. This setup works especially well for families who want flexibility, couples who like exploring local food scenes, and longer stays where cooking a few meals saves time and money.
Planning tip:
If you're staying 3+ nights, most guests recommend eating at Lionfish 2–3 times (especially for sunset dinners and easy breakfasts), then exploring nearby dining for variety. Red Hook is less than 5 minutes away and has casual spots like Caribbean Fish Market, Duffy's Love Shack, and Latitude 18.
If you're staying 3+ nights, most guests recommend eating at Lionfish 2–3 times (especially for sunset dinners and easy breakfasts), then exploring nearby dining for variety. Red Hook is less than 5 minutes away and has casual spots like Caribbean Fish Market, Duffy's Love Shack, and Latitude 18.
Lionfish Restaurant (Full Guide)
Lionfish Restaurant
Lionfish Restaurant is Point Pleasant Resort's signature on-site dining spot—offering Caribbean-inspired cuisine, fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and oceanfront views that make it a go-to for sunset dinners, casual family lunches, and easy breakfasts before heading to the beach or excursions.
What's on the menu:
- Breakfast: island-style omelets, fresh fruit, pastries, coffee, and smoothies
- Lunch: fish tacos, burgers, Caribbean salads, conch fritters, and tropical sandwiches
- Dinner: grilled mahi-mahi, jerk chicken, lobster (seasonal), Caribbean curries, and fresh catch of the day
- Drinks: rum cocktails (painkillers, mojitos, piña coladas), local beers, wine, and fresh juices
Best for:
- Sunset dinners: Lionfish has one of the best oceanfront views at Point Pleasant—perfect for couples and families who want a relaxed dinner with a view
- Easy breakfasts: when you don't want to cook or run out for food before an early activity day
- Casual lunches: post-beach or pool sessions when you want something quick and close
- First/last night dinners: many guests choose Lionfish on arrival or departure nights to avoid driving
Vibe:
Relaxed, breezy, and family-friendly. The setting feels more "beach club casual" than formal—open-air seating, ocean breeze, and a laid-back St. Thomas energy. It's a great fit for families with kids, couples who want something easygoing, and groups who want a low-stress meal without leaving the resort.
Strategy for your stay:
- Do Lionfish for sunset dinner at least once—it's the best on-site experience and usually the meal guests remember most
- Use it for breakfast on activity days when you want something fast before snorkeling, sailing, or exploring the island
- Skip it on nights you want to explore—Red Hook and nearby towns have great local spots worth checking out
- Go early for dinner (5:30–6:30pm) to get the best sunset timing and avoid waits during peak season
Top strength: oceanfront views
Best for: sunset dinners
Great for: families + couples
Casual Caribbean vibe
Smart Dining Tips (How to Plan Your Meals)
- Plan a grocery run early: Most villas have full kitchens—stock up at nearby markets in Red Hook for breakfasts, snacks, and easy dinners.
- Do Lionfish 2–3 times during your stay: It's best for sunset dinners, easy breakfasts, and nights you don't want to cook or drive.
- Explore Red Hook for variety: It's less than 5 minutes away and has casual spots like Caribbean Fish Market, Duffy's Love Shack, and Latitude 18.
- Save the "fancy" dinner for Charlotte Amalie or Frenchtown: If you want one upscale night out, head to spots like Oceana or Gladys' Café.
- Book Lionfish dinner early in peak season: Sunset tables go fast—reserve ahead if you're visiting December–April.
- Use your villa kitchen strategically: Cook breakfast and pack lunches for beach/excursion days to save time and money.
Planning rule that works:
If you're staying 4–5 nights, a good rotation is: 2 dinners at Lionfish (including one sunset meal), 1–2 nights exploring Red Hook or nearby towns, and 1–2 easy villa dinners. This gives you variety without overcommitting to one approach.
If you're staying 4–5 nights, a good rotation is: 2 dinners at Lionfish (including one sunset meal), 1–2 nights exploring Red Hook or nearby towns, and 1–2 easy villa dinners. This gives you variety without overcommitting to one approach.
FAQ: Point Pleasant Resort Dining
What restaurants are at Point Pleasant Resort?
Point Pleasant Resort has one on-site restaurant—Lionfish Restaurant—which serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner with Caribbean-inspired cuisine and oceanfront views. Most villas also include full kitchens or kitchenettes, so many guests cook some meals and explore nearby dining options in Red Hook.
Is Lionfish Restaurant good for families?
Yes—Lionfish Restaurant is family-friendly and casual. The menu includes kid-friendly options like burgers, fish tacos, and chicken, and the open-air setting works well for families with young children.
What's the best meal to have at Lionfish Restaurant?
Most guests recommend sunset dinner as the best meal at Lionfish—the oceanfront views are unbeatable, and the fresh seafood and Caribbean dishes feel most "St. Thomas." Breakfast is also a smart choice on activity days when you want something fast before heading out.
Are there restaurants near Point Pleasant Resort?
Yes—Red Hook is less than 5 minutes away and has casual spots like Caribbean Fish Market, Duffy's Love Shack, Latitude 18, and Petite Pump Room. For upscale dining, Charlotte Amalie and Frenchtown (15–20 minutes) have options like Oceana, Gladys' Café, and Haute Cuisine.
Do I need reservations at Lionfish Restaurant?
Reservations are recommended for sunset dinner, especially during peak season (December–April). Breakfast and lunch are usually walk-in friendly.
Is there a dress code at Lionfish Restaurant?
No formal dress code—resort casual is fine. Think shorts, sundresses, and sandals during the day. For dinner, casual island attire (no swimwear) is recommended.
Can I cook in my villa at Point Pleasant Resort?
Yes—most villas at Point Pleasant Resort include full kitchens or kitchenettes with stovetops, refrigerators, and cookware. Many guests stock up on groceries at nearby markets in Red Hook and cook breakfasts, lunches, or easy dinners to save time and money.
What's the best dining strategy for a 5-night stay?
A great rotation is: 2 dinners at Lionfish (including one sunset meal), 1–2 nights exploring Red Hook or nearby restaurants, and 1–2 easy villa dinners. Use your villa kitchen for breakfasts and pack lunches for beach/excursion days.
BOOK YOUR STAY NOW
Questions? Contact Us!
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades
More Point Pleasant Resort Guides
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Point Pleasant Resort:
- Best Rooms at Point Pleasant Resort (Top Suites Ranked by View, Value & Perks)
- Is Point Pleasant Resort Good for Weddings? (Packages, Venues, Costs & Real Pros/Cons)
- Best Time to Visit Point Pleasant Resort (Month-by-Month)
- Point Pleasant Resort Nightlife Guide: Parties, Shows, Bars & What to Expect