Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between Point Pleasant Resort and Windward Passage Hotel? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, dining, amenities, price & more so you can decide which stay is the best fit for your next St. Thomas getaway.
Best for travelers who want a hillside villa-style St. Thomas resort with kitchens, private outdoor space, multiple pools, and a quieter Water Bay setting.
Better for travelers who want a more traditional hotel base in Charlotte Amalie near the harbor, shopping, dining, and in-town convenience.
If you want more of a resort escape, Point Pleasant Resort is the stronger pick: hillside villas, private balconies or patios, three outdoor pools, a private Sugar Beach cove, and water views give it a more relaxed vacation feel.
If your priority is being in Charlotte Amalie with a straightforward hotel setup and easier access to the harbor area, Windward Passage Hotel is the more practical choice.
Bottom line: choose Point Pleasant Resort for space, views, kitchens, pools, and a tucked-away East End setting; choose Windward Passage Hotel for a city-harbor stay with simpler logistics in Charlotte Amalie.
| Category | Point Pleasant Resort | Windward Passage Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | Hillside, villa-style all-ages resort overlooking Water Bay, with lush grounds, private outdoor spaces, and a quieter island-resort atmosphere. | Traditional Charlotte Amalie hotel with a more urban harbor-area feel, better suited to travelers who want convenience over a secluded resort setting. |
| Location | On a 15-acre hillside preserve on the East End of St. Thomas, overlooking Water Bay and the Caribbean Sea. | In Charlotte Amalie near the harbor, better for travelers who want to stay close to town activity and transportation convenience. |
| Rooms & Suites | Individually decorated guestrooms and villas with fully equipped kitchens and private balconies or patios. | More conventional hotel-style rooms, better for shorter stays or travelers who do not need a kitchen or villa-style layout. |
| Dining | Two on-site dining venues are listed, including casual waterfront dining and a more polished dinner option; current restaurant names and seasonal openings should be reconfirmed. | Best treated as a city-hotel dining base, with the advantage of being near Charlotte Amalie restaurants rather than a self-contained resort dining experience. |
| Pools & Beach | Three outdoor pools plus the resort’s private Sugar Beach cove for swimming, snorkeling, and a quieter coastal setting. | More of a harbor-area hotel stay than a beach-resort experience; best for guests who plan to explore beaches elsewhere on St. Thomas. |
| Kids & Family | Children of all ages are welcome, babysitting/child care is listed, and kitchen-equipped villas can work well for families—though hillside terrain and outdoor spaces require care. | Works for families who prefer a central hotel base, but it is less resort-oriented than Point Pleasant for pool-and-beach downtime. |
| Price & Value | Best value for travelers who will use the kitchens, pools, private beach, views, and resort setting. | Best value for travelers who care more about Charlotte Amalie access and a practical hotel base than villa space or resort grounds. |
Rooms at Point Pleasant Resort feel more residential than standard hotel rooms, with individually decorated villas and guestrooms spread across a hillside setting.
Point Pleasant is the better pick if you want more room independence, a villa-style setup, and a quieter resort atmosphere.
Windward Passage Hotel is the simpler choice if you prefer a traditional hotel format in Charlotte Amalie rather than a hillside villa resort.
If you want a straightforward hotel base near the harbor, Windward Passage Hotel is the more practical fit.
Dining at Point Pleasant Resort centers on its on-site venues, including relaxed waterfront dining and a more elevated dinner setting, though current names and seasonal availability should be checked before arrival.
Expect:
Windward Passage Hotel makes the most sense for travelers who want to use Charlotte Amalie as their dining base rather than relying on a resort-style restaurant lineup.
If you want kitchens and on-resort meals, Point Pleasant has the edge; if you want town dining convenience, Windward Passage is the easier base.
Point Pleasant Resort is much stronger for travelers who want pool time and a coastal resort feel, with three outdoor pools and its own private Sugar Beach cove.
Windward Passage Hotel is better viewed as a Charlotte Amalie harbor-area base, not the stronger choice for a private beach resort experience.
If pools, a private cove, and a hillside resort setting matter most, Point Pleasant Resort is the clear winner.
Point Pleasant Resort welcomes children of all ages and can work well for families who value kitchens, separate-feeling villa space, pools, and a quieter East End setting.
Windward Passage Hotel is the more straightforward option for families who want a central Charlotte Amalie hotel base rather than a resort spread across hillside grounds.
If your family wants kitchens, pools, and a quieter resort setting, Point Pleasant is stronger; if you want a central hotel base, Windward Passage is simpler.
Point Pleasant Resort offers the most value when you will actually use its resort-style advantages: kitchens, private outdoor space, three pools, the private beach cove, and the hillside views.
Windward Passage Hotel is the better value if your plans center on Charlotte Amalie and you want a practical place to sleep between town, harbor, and island activities.
Choose Point Pleasant if you want a relaxed all-ages resort with villa-style rooms, kitchens, private balconies or patios, three pools, a private beach cove, and Water Bay views.
Windward Passage is the better pick if you want a traditional hotel in Charlotte Amalie with easier access to the harbor area and town-based plans.
For families, longer stays, and travelers who want more space and self-catering flexibility, Point Pleasant Resort is the stronger vacation-style choice.
If you want a simpler city-hotel stay and plan to spend more time out exploring than relaxing at the resort, Windward Passage Hotel makes more sense.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Point Pleasant Resort:
