Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between Point Pleasant Resort and Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort is the best fit.
Best for travelers who want a hillside St. Thomas condo-resort with kitchen-equipped villas, big water views, pools, and a private beach.
Better for travelers who want a more self-contained private-island luxury resort experience with a marina, spa positioning, and a more exclusive getaway feel.
If you want an easy St. Thomas base with individually decorated villas, full kitchens, balconies or patios, three outdoor pools, and access to the resort’s Sugar Beach, Point Pleasant Resort is the more practical pick.
If your priority is a private-island setting with a marina-centered luxury atmosphere and a stronger resort-escape feel, Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina is the better fit.
Bottom line: choose Point Pleasant Resort for villa-style space, St. Thomas convenience, and a hillside beach-resort feel; choose Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina for a more secluded private-island luxury stay.
| Category | Point Pleasant Resort | Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | All-ages hillside condo-resort with individually decorated villas, Caribbean views, a relaxed pace, and a practical St. Thomas home-base feel. | Private-island luxury resort with a marina-forward setting, spa positioning, and a more secluded, destination-resort atmosphere. |
| Location | On 15 lush hillside acres overlooking Water Bay and the Caribbean Sea on the East End of St. Thomas. | On Scrub Island, offering a more removed island-resort experience centered around privacy, water access, and marina-style travel. |
| Rooms & Suites | Individually decorated guestrooms and villas with fully equipped kitchens plus private balconies or patios—great for travelers who want more independence. | More traditional luxury-resort accommodations in a private-island setting, better for guests who want the resort itself to be the main experience. |
| Dining | Two on-site restaurants are listed, with current resort materials naming Sun & Sea Bar & Grill and Lionfish Restaurant; exact seasonal availability should be reconfirmed. | Better suited to travelers who want a more self-contained resort dining experience as part of a private-island stay. |
| Pools & Beach | Three outdoor pools, including the Waterfront Pool and Terrace Pool, plus the resort’s private Sugar Beach for swimming or snorkeling. | A private-island beach-and-marina setting, better for guests who want the water and resort grounds to feel more removed from the main island. |
| Kids & Family | Children of all ages are welcome, babysitting/child care is listed, though some balconies, patios, terraces, and hillside areas may require extra care. | Can work for families or couples who prefer a higher-end island escape, though the strongest draw is the secluded private-island resort setting. |
| Price & Value | Best value for travelers who want kitchen-equipped villa space, multiple pools, a private beach, and a convenient East End St. Thomas base. | Best value for travelers who will use and appreciate the private-island setting, marina access, and more exclusive resort atmosphere. |
Rooms at Point Pleasant Resort are individually decorated villa-style accommodations, with practical features that make longer or more independent stays easier.
Point Pleasant is the better pick if you want space, self-catering flexibility, and a hillside St. Thomas base rather than a fully enclosed luxury-resort bubble.
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina is the stronger choice for travelers who want the accommodations to be part of a polished private-island resort experience.
If you want a more tucked-away, luxury island-resort feel, Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina has the edge; if you want kitchens and villa flexibility, Point Pleasant fits better.
Dining at Point Pleasant Resort is anchored by on-site venues plus the flexibility of in-villa kitchens, making it a good fit for travelers who do not want every meal to feel resort-programmed.
Expect:
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina is better for travelers who prefer a more contained private-island dining setup, where the resort environment is central to the evening.
If dining independence and kitchen flexibility matter, Point Pleasant is easier; if private-island convenience is the priority, Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina is the better match.
Point Pleasant Resort has a strong pool-and-beach setup for a villa-style property, with multiple outdoor pools spread across the hillside and its own private beach.
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina offers the more secluded waterfront feel, with the appeal of being on a private island rather than on a larger, busier main island.
If you want St. Thomas views, pools, and a private cove, Point Pleasant works beautifully; if you want a more private-island waterfront escape, Scrub Island has the stronger sense of seclusion.
Point Pleasant Resort welcomes children of all ages and can work well for families who value kitchen-equipped accommodations, pool options, and a less formal resort rhythm.
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina can suit families who want a more immersive island-resort stay, but its strongest appeal is the private-island setting and resort atmosphere.
If your family wants kitchens, pools, and a practical St. Thomas base, Point Pleasant is easier; if the trip is built around a private-island resort experience, Scrub Island is more compelling.
Point Pleasant Resort offers the most value when you want villa-style space, kitchen flexibility, scenic views, and access to pools and a private beach without needing a fully enclosed luxury island setup.
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina is the better value if the private-island setting, marina atmosphere, and more secluded luxury feel are central to why you are booking.
Choose Point Pleasant if you want kitchen-equipped villas, private balconies or patios, three pools, Sugar Beach, and a scenic hillside base on St. Thomas.
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina is the better pick for travelers who want a private-island luxury resort with a marina-centered, secluded getaway feel.
For families, longer stays, or travelers who like the option to cook, spread out, and explore from a St. Thomas base, Point Pleasant Resort is the more flexible choice.
If you want the trip to revolve around privacy, water access, and a more exclusive island-resort atmosphere, Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina is the stronger fit.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Point Pleasant Resort:
